Nobody Knows What Is in the Box

An inherited collection typically has no inventory, no current valuations, and several beneficiaries with sincere and conflicting recollections. Without a neutral record made before anything is distributed, the division becomes a dispute about memory, and those are the family arguments that last decades.

Time also works against an inherited collection in a way that surprises families. Items get taken informally for safekeeping by different people with entirely good intentions, and within a few months nobody can reconstruct what was originally there or who has what.

• Inventory everything before anything is distributed or sold.
• Photograph each item individually.
• Record condition, so later questions have an answer.
• Get a qualified appraisal before dividing by value.
• Store it somewhere neutral while decisions are made.

Holding a collection somewhere neutral removes the question of who is looking after it, which is frequently the thing generating friction rather than the distribution itself.

It also means the inventory is made once, by one party, before anything moves — which is the document every subsequent conversation depends on and the one that cannot be created later.

1. 01Inventory item by item with photographs, on intake.
2. 02Hold the collection neutrally while the estate is resolved.
3. 03Release only on the authority the estate documents establish.
4. 04Provide records to the personal representative and their counsel.
5. 05Log every access and every release.

Do the inventory before anything leaves the house. Once items have been distributed informally — a ring taken by one relative, a watch by another — reconstructing what existed becomes impossible, and every subsequent conversation is about somebody's memory.

All 5 →